Table 4. Summary of Systematic Reviews of the Effectiveness of Oral Health Promotion and Education

Review Knowledge level Oral hygiene behaviors Caries prevention
Brown, 199450
OHP and OHE, 57 studies
Most interventions are effective in increasing knowledge in the short term, little evidence for longer-term effects.
(3 studies)
One-on-one instruction, repeated contact, and participant involvement lead to short-term improvement, but no longer-term effects.
(13 studies)
Reduction in caries if target was use of fluoride-containing product.
(3 studies)
Kay, 199651
OHE, 37 studies
Knowledge levels are consistently raised by interventions; more effective interventions tended to be more expensive.
(14 studies)
Plaque removal programs are generally effective in short term, but no long-term benefits.
(15 studies)
No evidence that dental health education interventions affect caries levels.
(4 studies)
Sprod, 199652
OHP, 70 studies
Knowledge can be easily improved using many approaches, but may fade, may need reinforcement.  Has limited effect on behavior change when used alone.
(NR)
Behavior change is effected by active involvement, repetition, and continued support.  Most effective methods address social, personal,  environmental, and technical factors.
(NR)
Very few studies, little evidence of long-term gain.
(NR)
Kay, 199853
OHP, 164 studies
Knowledge levels are invariably altered by interventions, but alterations not related to changes in behavior or health.
(NR)
Simple instruction alters behavior in short term, reducing plaque levels; no lasting effect.
(20 RCTs)
Meta-analysis indicates 1.8 surface reduction associated with interventions increasing use of fluorides.
(7 RCTs)

Note:  NR, number of studies not reported; OHP indicates oral health promotion; OHE, oral health education; RCT, randomized controlled trials.

Return to Document